My friend Gary Bauer has proposed some
questions for you to ask your Senators and
Representative about ObamaCare. I'm asking
all AFA supporters to get a group together
and go to your Senators and Representative
offices and ask these questions. Most
Senators and Representatives have Townhall
meetings in their district during their
August break. Get the schedule and attend
the meetings. Urge others to do the same.
Have different groups at different
locations to ask these questions to make
sure the Congressman is consistent.
Here are Gary's recommendations.
Yesterday, President Obama conceded that
there probably won't be a vote on
healthcare reform until "the end of
September or the middle of October." That
means you have August to attend town hall
meetings with your representative and
senators, stop by their congressional
offices, write letters to the editor and
educate your friends and family members
about the dangers of socialized medicine.
To help you in that effort, we’ve produced
a short list of key concerns and
questions, which are copied below. Please
share this report with like-minded folks
and those who may be undecided and willing
to listen. Thank you for everything you do
to defend our shared values in your
community!
1. ABORTION
Pro-choice groups, like NARAL and Planned
Parenthood, are demanding that abortion be
covered in any healthcare reform bill. In
a recent interview with Politico,
Laurie Rubiner, vice president for public
policy and advocacy at Planned Parenthood,
defends this demand by saying, "the
alternative would be slashing benefits for
millions of women who currently have
[private] coverage for abortions..." In
addition, key administration officials
refuse to rule out abortion coverage. When
asked on Fox News Sunday whether
taxpayer money would go to pay for
abortions, White House Budget Director
Peter Orszag replied, "I am not prepared
to say explicitly that right now. It's
obviously a controversial issue, and it's
one of the questions that is playing out
in this debate."
Pro-life senators on the Senate's
Health, Education, Labor and Pensions
Committee forced a roll call vote on the
issue when Senator Barbara Mikulski (D-MD)
attempted to add an amendment to the
healthcare bill that would, in her words,
"include women's health clinics that
provide comprehensive services...deemed
medically necessary or appropriate." She
admitted that such "health clinics" would
include Planned Parenthood. The pro-life
amendment to prohibit funding of abortion
lost 11-to-12.
Question for your Congressmen: Will you
oppose any healthcare reform bill that
uses my tax dollars to pay for abortions?
2. EUTHANASIA
In a recent New York Post column,
Betsy McCaughey, a former lieutenant
governor of New York and health care
expert, wrote:
"One
troubling provision of the House bill
compels seniors to submit to a counseling
session every five years (and more often
if they become sick or go into a nursing
home) about alternatives for end-of-life
care (House bill, p. 425-430). The
sessions cover highly sensitive matters
such as whether to receive antibiotics and
'the use of artificially administered
nutrition and hydration.' This mandate
invites abuse, and seniors could easily be
pushed to refuse care."
Question for your Congressmen: Will you
oppose any healthcare reform bill that in
any way promotes euthanasia?
3. COST
The United States faces a debt crisis.
According to many analysts, including
Senator Judd Gregg (who is so respected by
President Obama that he offered Gregg the
post of Secretary of Commerce), the Obama
budget will give us $11 trillion of debt
at the end of five years and $17 trillion
of debt at the end of ten years.
(Source:
PolitiFact.com)
Question for your Congressmen: Why is
Congress and the president pushing through
a healthcare bill that would cost another
trillion dollars over the next ten years?
Shouldn't we concentrate on getting the
debt under control first?
4. RATIONING CARE
According to a July 15th report by The
Hill, "The House bill would be paid
for by roughly $500 billion in Medicare
and Medicaid cuts..." These "cuts" would
come as millions of Americans are
retiring. Logic suggests that if we are
"cutting" hundreds of billions of dollars
healthcare would have to be limited or
rationed in someway to accommodate more
people. And seniors would be most affected
by Medicare cuts.
In addition, advisors to President
Obama, such as Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel,
brother of White House Chief of Staff Rahm
Emanuel, have suggested that healthcare
should be rationed to certain individuals.
Dr. Emanuel once wrote that "services
provided to individuals who are
irreversibly prevented from being or
becoming participating citizens...should
not be guaranteed. An obvious example is
not guaranteeing health services to
patients with dementia."
(Source:
http://www.ncpa.org/pdfs/Where_Civic_Republicanism_and_
Deliberative_Democracy_Meet.pdf)
Question for your Congressmen: How can
government promise to do more with less?
Will you oppose any healthcare reform bill
that in any way limits my access to
healthcare or medicines recommended by my
doctor?
5. MORE BURDENS ON SMALL
BUSINESSES
Despite a 9.5% (and rising) unemployment
rate, the healthcare bill in the House
imposes a new 8% payroll tax on small
businesses with payrolls of $400,000 or
more that don't provide health insurance
for their employees. This is in addition
to the current 15% payroll tax. What this
means is that any employer with a payroll
of $400,000 dollars or higher will have to
pay at least 25% above the salary just to
hire someone. Common sense tells you that
any struggling small business will likely
lay off workers to avoid this additional
tax. On the other hand, if the tax is
cheaper than the cost of health insurance,
larger businesses may opt to cancel their
health insurance, forcing employees into
the government’s "public option," and
simply pay the 8% fine. (Source: Wall
Street Journal, July 15, 2009)
Question for your Congressmen: Why are
you imposing additional mandates and taxes
on small businesses, which create the
overwhelming majority of new jobs, in the
middle of a severe recession?
6. QUALITY CARE
American healthcare is better than that in
European countries with socialized
medicine. The German breast cancer
mortality rate is 52% higher than in the
United States. Prostate cancer mortality
is 604% higher in the United Kingdom and
457% higher in Norway than in the United
States. Canadian healthcare lags behind
the United States too. Canadian patients
wait twice as long to see a specialist for
hip surgery or cancer than we do in the
United States. Most Americans say they are
satisfied with the U.S. health care
system, but more than 70% of Germans,
Canadians, Australians, New Zealanders and
Britons say that their systems need
"fundamental change" or "complete
rebuilding." (Source: National Center for
Policy Analysis.)
In an editorial on July 26th, the
Washington Post criticized President
Obama for not "leveling about the
consequences of change" when it comes to
healthcare costs versus quality. Here's
what the Post wrote: "The Congressional
Budget Office estimates that new
technology accounts for about half the
increase in health-care costs over the
past several decades. This, for the most
part, is a good thing. Adjusted for
inflation, health-care spending per person
is six times what it was 40 years ago. But
no one today would settle for 1960s-style
medicine."
Question for your Congressmen: Why are
you trying to force us in the direction of
more government involvement in healthcare
when everywhere government-run healthcare
has been tried, quality declines and care
is rationed?
7. THE PEOPLE ARE BEING IGNORED
According to a recent poll, just 23% of
voters believe healthcare reform
legislation will lower costs, while 53%
believe it will lead to more expensive
care. By a margin of 50% to 23%, voters
believe that "reform" legislation will
make the quality of care decline. And
while voters believe they will get worse
care at higher costs, 78% also believe
that healthcare reform will result in
middle class tax hikes. In addition, a
recent Fox News poll found that
91% of those surveyed have health
insurance, 84% said that the quality of
their health insurance was either
excellent or good and 83% said the quality
of health care they receive from their
private insurance is either good or
excellent. And only 12% of those surveyed
said reforming health care was the most
important issue Congress should be working
on right now. (Source: Rasmussen Reports,
July 28, 2009 and Fox News poll July 23,
2009.)
Question for your Congressmen: Why are
you and the White House rushing this bill
through Congress and ignoring the concerns
of the American people?
8. LOSS OF FREEDOM
The healthcare reform legislation under
consideration in the House will eventually
force all Americans into a
government-approved plan. After a
five-year grace period, every new
insurance policy will have to comply with
government mandates, and any policy
changes – "altering co-pays, deductibles,
or even switching coverage for this or
that drug" – invalidates your previous
coverage and forces you to choose a
government "qualified" plan. In addition,
the House plan mandates coverage for every
individual. If you are self-employed or
choose not buy insurance for whatever
reason, the bill imposes a "healthcare
tax" of 2.5% of your income. (Source:
CNNMoney.com, July 24, 2009 and
Bloomberg.com, July 15, 2009)
Question for your Congressmen: Why do
you believe bureaucrats can make better
decisions than me about what kind of
health insurance I should have? And will
you guarantee that any healthcare reform
bill passed by Congress will always allow
me to choose my own doctor?
9. RACIAL PREFERENCES
Do you care about the race of a doctor who
is getting ready to operate on you? Of
course not. Most Americans want their
doctor to be the best professional
available regardless of race or ethnic
background. But congressional liberals
have a different idea. On page 909 of the
House bill, grants to medical schools will
be awarded "to entities that have a
demonstrated record of the
following...training individuals who are
from underrepresented minority groups or
disadvantaged backgrounds." (Source:
Investors Business Daily, July 27, 2009)
Question for your Congressmen: Why are
you throwing affirmative action/racial set
asides into a healthcare reform bill?
10. PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS
President Obama has repeatedly said that
"no insurance company will be allowed to
deny you coverage because of a
pre-existing medical condition." That
sounds wonderful until you apply common
sense, which is in short supply in
Washington. What if we made a law that
allowed you to buy car insurance after you
got into an accident and that required the
insurance company to pay for the damage?
Wouldn’t many people just wait for an
accident before buying insurance? Why
wouldn’t many Americans wait until they
were sick to buy health insurance?
Question for your Congressmen: Isn't it
clear that this provision would drive up
the cost of health insurance for
everyone?